Tiki Margarita (with Grapefruit & Allspice Dram)
The post may contain affiliate links.
This Tiki Margarita (with Grapefruit & Allspice Dram) blends a classic tequila margarita with a tiki-bar spice cabinet, for a result that’s bold and impossible to put down. Silver tequila, orange liqueur, and fresh grapefruit get a hit of allspice dram, a turbinado sugar rim, and a dusting of nutmeg you smell before your first sip.
Here are a few more cocktails you can try: Cranberry Moscow Mule, The Tiki Rita Margarita, The Cool Coquito Cocktail, Fresh Orange Crush Cocktail, Pineapple Coconut Moscow Mule, Frozen Blood Orange Margarita, and Frozen Pear Margarita Cocktail

When you’re in the mood for a nice, not-so-regular margarita, this cocktail is a smash hitābut take caution, because it can definitely sneak up on you. Believe me, I know. š
It’s refreshing and gets its added spice from the allspice dramāa tasty rum-based liqueur flavored with allspice berries that tastes like a combination of clove, cinnamon, and black pepper all at once. It’s a staple behind every serious tiki bar, and it turns a familiar margarita into something that tastes far more complex than five minutes of work should allow.
Clean silver tequila carries the spice, orange liqueur and simple syrup round out the sweetness, and a mix of tart grapefruit and lemon juice keeps every sip bright and lively. A hard shake chills the drink, the sugar rim adds a sweet note to every sip, and fresh nutmeg on top ties it all together with a toasty, aromatic finish. It’s a margarita that works as well at a fall dinner party as it does on a summer patio.
What you’ll love about this recipe:
Ingredients you’ll need to make a Tiki Margarita:
- Simple syrup (Granulated sugar + Water): Rounds out the sweetness and smooths the bite of the tequila and citrus.
- Turbinado sugar: For the rim. These large, golden crystals carry a light molasses flavor and a satisfying crunch that plain sugar can’t match. Coarse salt works too if you prefer a classic margarita rim.
- Lime: A lime wedge moistens the rim so the sugar sticks, and a lime wheel serves as a garnish.
- Silver tequila: The backbone of the drink. Unaged blanco tequila has a clean, peppery agave flavor that stands up to the spice without getting lost.
- Fresh grapefruit juice: Adds tartness with a slight bitter edge that keeps the sweet components in check. It’s a natural partner for tequila.
- Allspice dram: The tiki star. This dark, spiced liqueur (sometimes called pimento dram) tastes of allspice, clove, and cinnamon, giving the cocktail its signature personality.
- Orange liqueur: The classic margarita sweetener. Cointreau or a quality triple sec adds bright orange flavor and a little extra strength.
- Fresh lemon juice: A small amount sharpens the citrus and brightens the whole drink.
- Ice: Ice in the shaker chills and slightly dilutes the drink; fresh ice in the glass keeps it cold to the last sip.
- Ground nutmeg: The finishing touch. A light dusting on top adds a toasty, sweet-spiced aroma that echoes the allspice dram.

How to make a Tiki Rita Margarita:
- Make the simple syrup. Stir equal parts sugar and warm water in a small cup or measuring cup until the sugar fully dissolves, about 1-2 minutes. Let it cool.
- Rim the glass. Spread turbinado sugar on a small plate, run a lime wedge around the rim of a rocks glass, then roll the edge through the sugar until it’s evenly coated. Fill the glass with fresh ice.
- Shake the cocktail. Add the tequila, grapefruit juice, allspice dram, orange liqueur, lemon juice, simple syrup, and ice to a cocktail shaker. Shake hard for 15-20 seconds, until the shaker is frosty.
- Strain, garnish, and serve. Strain the margarita into the prepared glass, top with a light dusting of ground nutmeg, add a lime wheel, and serve right away.
Tips
Cocktail Tips & Tricks
- Bottled grapefruit and lemon juice taste flat and slightly metallic next to fresh. Half a grapefruit gives you far more than the ½ ounce you need, so enjoy the rest with breakfast.
- Between the simple syrup, orange liqueur, and allspice dram, this margarita leans sweet. If you like it tarter, cut the simple syrup to ½ ounce or squeeze in the juice of half the lime.
- Reposado tequila adds a little vanilla and oak that plays well with the spice, and mezcal (or half tequila, half mezcal) adds a smoky edge. For a sweet-salty rim, mix the turbinado sugar with a little flaky sea salt.
- If you have a whole nutmeg and a microplane, a few quick passes over the top of the drink give you a much more aromatic finish than pre-ground.

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips
- Make ahead: The simple syrup can be made up to 1 month in advance. For a party, stir together the tequila, allspice dram, orange liqueur, and simple syrup in a pitcher up to 2 days ahead and refrigerate. Add the fresh grapefruit and lemon juice the day you serve, then shake each drink with ice to order.
- Storage: Store simple syrup in a sealed jar in the refrigerator for up to 1 month; discard it if it turns cloudy. Fresh citrus juice is best within 24 hours. Don’t store finished, shaken cocktails, since they lose their chill, froth, and fresh citrus flavor within minutes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is allspice dram, and is there a substitute? Allspice dram (also called pimento dram) is a Jamaican-style liqueur made by steeping allspice berries in rum and sweetening it. It tastes like clove, cinnamon, and black pepper rolled into one. St. Elizabeth is the most common brand. If you can’t find it, use ½ ounce of spiced rum plus ¼ ounce of extra simple syrup and a small extra dusting of nutmeg. It won’t be identical, but it brings a similar spiced character.
What makes a margarita “tiki”? Tiki cocktails are known for layering spirits, fresh citrus, and baking spices like allspice, cinnamon, and nutmeg. This recipe keeps the tequila-orange-citrus structure of a margarita but adds allspice dram and a nutmeg garnish, borrowing the spiced, tropical character of classic tiki drinks.
Can I make this Tiki Margarita without a cocktail shaker? Yes. A mason jar or any container with a tight-fitting lid works perfectly. Add the ingredients and ice, seal it tightly, and shake just as you would with a shaker. Then hold the lid slightly ajar or use a small strainer to pour the drink over fresh ice.
Print
Tiki Margarita (with Grapefruit & Allspice)
Tiki Margarita with silver tequila, allspice dram, fresh grapefruit, and a sugar rim. A bold, spiced craft cocktail ready in 5 minutes!
- Total Time: 5 minutes
- Yield: 1 1x
Ingredients
Simple Syrup:
- 3 tbsp granulated sugar
- 3 tbsp warm water
Rim and Garnish:
- 2–3 tbsp turbinado sugar (or coarse salt)
- 1 lime, cut into wedges and wheels
Tiki Margarita:
- 2 oz silver tequila
- 1/2 oz fresh grapefruit juice
- 1 oz allspice dram
- 1 oz orange liqueur
- 1/4 oz fresh lemon juice
- 1 oz simple syrup
- 1 cup ice, for shaking, plus more for serving
- Dash of ground nutmeg, for garnish
Instructions
- Make the simple syrup. Add the sugar and warm water to a small cup and stir until the sugar fully dissolves and the syrup looks clear, about 1-2 minutes. Let it cool for a few minutes before using.
- Rim the glass. Sprinkle the turbinado sugar onto a small plate. Run a lime wedge around the rim of a double rocks glass, then turn the glass upside down and roll the edge through the sugar until it’s evenly coated. Fill the glass with fresh ice and set it aside.
- Build the cocktail. In a cocktail shaker, add the tequila, grapefruit juice, allspice dram, orange liqueur, lemon juice, and 1 ounce of the simple syrup. Add 1 cup of ice.
- Shake. Seal the shaker tightly and shake hard for 15-20 seconds, until the outside of the shaker feels very cold and looks frosty.
- Strain and garnish. Strain the margarita into the prepared glass. Top with a dash of ground nutmeg and garnish with a lime wheel. Serve immediately.
Equipment
Buy Now ā Notes
Bottled grapefruit and lemon juice taste flat and slightly metallic next to fresh. Half a grapefruit gives you far more than the ½ ounce you need, so enjoy the rest with breakfast.
Between the simple syrup, orange liqueur, and allspice dram, this margarita leans sweet. If you like it tarter, cut the simple syrup to ½ ounce or squeeze in the juice of half the lime.
Reposado tequila adds a little vanilla and oak that plays well with the spice, and mezcal (or half tequila, half mezcal) adds a smoky, campfire edge. For a sweet-salty rim, mix the turbinado sugar with a little flaky sea salt.
If you have a whole nutmeg and a microplane, a few quick passes over the top of the drink give you a much more aromatic finish than pre-ground.
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 1 cocktail made with 80-proof tequila, Cointreau, St. Elizabeth Allspice Dram, and a turbinado sugar rim
- Calories: 388
- Sugar: 38 g
- Sodium: 3 mg
- Fat: 0 g
- Saturated Fat: 0 g
- Carbohydrates: 40 g
- Fiber: 0 g
- Protein: 0.2 g


This has become my fav drink. I wanted to make something with the allspice dram (holiday reminiscent) and this one came up and mixed margaritas which is my go to and the taste of fall/winter. Iāve remade this now four times and itās always fantastic. You can use a little less of the allspice, but if you love that cinnamon clove taste go for the full amount. Thank you for making this and sharing it!
Thanks for sharing your feedback, Morgan! We love allspice dram and are always looking for ways to use it in a cocktail recipe. It is perfect for those holiday vibes!
It’s refreshing, sweetly satisfying, with all the things you love about a margarita. My guests enjoyed them!